Skip to main content

The Racial Disparity in Police Violence


By: Rory Kramer and Brianna Remster
Villanova University


Accusations of racial bias in police use of force have long been a touchstone for civil unrest in the United States. In the 1960s, cities across the country saw massive protests and violence, including Watts, Detroit, and Philadelphia. In the 1980s, Miami residents rioted after police were acquitted in the death of Arthur McDuffie, presaging the 1992 Los Angeles riots. Police violence also triggered riots in the early 21stcentury in Cincinnati and, most recently, police violence energized a national movement under the #BlackLivesMatter moniker in response to the deaths of young Black victims such as Michael Brown in Ferguson, Freddie Gray in Baltimore, Tamir Rice in Cleveland, and Laquan McDonald in Chicago. Under the competing banner of #BlueLivesMatter, advocates suggest that Black people are more likely to be doing something wrong during police encounters than White people, thus precipitating police use of force. Despite these competing explanations for police violence, no recent systematic research testing these propositions exists.
 
In our article “Stop, Frisk, and Assault? Racial Disparities in Police Use of Force during Investigatory Stops," we offer a systematic look at race and age inequities in police violence in New York City. New York was amongst the first departments to provide detailed data for every stop-and-frisk performed in the city. At its height, over half a million people a year were stopped by police as part of NYC’s proactive policing strategy. Our study examines over 2 million stops from 2007-2014 of Black and White civilians, observing whether or not those stops include police use of force and more narrowly, whether or not police draw their guns (police are trained to be prepared to use lethal force if they draw their weapon).
 
Our findings show that police are more likely to use force, including potential lethal force, against Black civilians than Whites, after adjusting for the civilian’s behavior during the encounter, the neighborhood in which the stop occurred, and other characteristics of both the stop and the civilian. In fact, the racial disparity is largest for potential lethal force when police locate evidence of criminal behavior during a stop, when stereotypes of Black persons as criminal and dangerous may be especially powerful. Further, we find that Black youth are more likely to be subjected to police violence than White youth, which resulted in thousands of additional instances of police violence against young Black men per year in New York alone.
 
We also examined whether stop-and-frisk reforms have affected the racial disparity in experiencing force. New York dramatically reduced its use of investigatory stops, from approximately half a million per year to fewer than 50,000 annually. This was in part because a federal judge declared the NYPD’s execution of stop-and-frisk to be unconstitutional, due to racial disparities in who was stopped. In short, our findings indicate that this reform has had little effect on the racial disparity in police violence—Black civilians remain more likely to experience force than White civilians—but because of the extraordinary decline in stops, thousands fewer New Yorkers, primarily Black, are subjected to police violence annually. Moreover, even with this change, crime has continued to stay low. Hence, policy changes can reduce police violence, but much work remains to be done to reduce the racial disparity in this violence.

Popular posts from this blog

On writing

By Susan Sterett
Law & Society Review Co-Editor

One thing I know for sure after having co-edited Law and Society Review for almost three years is that just about every college and university would like more publications from faculty members. Many colleges and universities around the world want people to write for peer-reviewed journals, so like other journals, Law and Society Review has been getting an increasing number of submissions. Some journals have big backlogs. Some journals have stopped accepting submissions. Everyone is overwhelmed with content. How can you prepare your paper for LSR? This post will point to a few resources that could help, based in my experience from editing, conversations with other editors, and my conversations at the wonderful 2017 sociolegal studies early career workshop at the University of Cape Town. All have made me rethink how I submit to journals.

A few thoughts, most of which are readily found on the internet. Even so, many people may no…

Law & Society Review is pleased to announce two opportunities for scholars who are from or who write about the Global South. Both opportunities have early January deadlines.

The first opportunity is the Sociolegal Studies Early Career Writing Workshop, March 21-23, 2019, at the University of Cape Town. This intensive workshop, co-sponsored by Law & Society Review, is for a small group of early career scholars from any university in Africa to receive feedback on papers in progress and mentoring on writing/publishing processes. The goal is to help one another toward writing goals and publication. The Workshop will cover travel expenses and accommodation. Applications (including draft paper and letter of reference) are due January 14, 2019. For details, please visit the Early Career Workshop website here. For additional questions, contact pbl-cls@uct.ac.za.

Another opportunity is the Law and Society in Africa conference, April 1-3, 2019, organized by American University Cairo's Law & Society Research Unit. The first Law and Society in Africa Conference, held in South Africa in 2016, was a great success, with more than 100 attendees…

How do text messages complicate contemporary sexual assault adjudication?

By Heather Hlavka and Sameena Mulla 
Department of Social and Cultural Sciences, Marquette University


“There’s no video, no injury. It’s purely one hundred percent ‘he said, she said.’ They had a terrible relationship. They were nasty to each other and they don’t get along well, probably never will. But there is no evidence to support the state’s case, other than their words.” Our article, “’That’s How She Talks’: Animating Text Message Evidence in the Sexual Assault Trial,” begins with these familiar words offered by a defense attorney during a sexual assault trial in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The oft-invoked trope of “he said, she said” in cases of sexual violence suggests that without third-party eye witness testimony or material evidence, sexual assault allegations rest on conflicting reports provided by victims, the accused, and other witnesses. But how do trial attorneys reinvent this trope when the words of the witnesses are preserved as text messages?

Text messages are recorded co…