Skip to main content

The Christian Conservative Moves to Transform Law Through Legal Education

By Joshua C. Wilson, University of Denver
Amanda Hollis-Brusky, Pomona College

Picture:Wilson, Joshua C. 2018. Photograph. Liberty Law, Lynchburg, VA

 As “gatekeepers to the profession,” institutions of legal education are positioned to provide various forms of essential capital for movements interested in transforming law. They attract, socialize, and credential lawyers (human capital); establish or provide inroads to networks for group advancement (social capital); and create, spread, and legitimate ideas within the legal, political, and wider public's (intellectual and cultural capital).

In our article,"Higher Law: Can Christian Conservatives Transform Law Through Legal Education?", we analyze how three leading Christian conservative law schools and one training program organize themselves to produce the kinds of capital (human, intellectual, social, cultural) needed to effectively change the law.

Scholarship corroborates the proposition that law schools and legal education are an important part of the broader “support structure” for legal and constitutional development. From the New Deal Revolution in the 1930s and 40s and the birth of legal liberalism, to the “Rights Revolution” of the mid-20th Century, to the conservative counterrevolution begun in the 1980s and continuing today through to the Supreme Court, we see how sweeping changes in law and legal culture originated in changes in law schools, legal training and education. Moreover, recent high-profile investments in legal education by conservative patrons and donors such as the Koch Brothers, the Olin Foundation, and the Scaife Foundation to establish beach heads in the legal academy for conservatives who reject the liberal legal orthodoxy demonstrate the widely-held belief that American law schools are a critical lynchpin in the battle for control over the law.

Parallel to secular conservative’s organized entry into the fight to control law and law schools was the creation of the modern Christian Right. While the product of decades of changes, the modern Christian Right arguably entered American politics as an identifiable force in the 1980s. Starting mainly in the traditional venues of electoral politics, by the 1990s, leaders within the movement recognized the need to expand their fight into the nation’s courts, and so they created Christian conservative legal organizations (CCLOs) such as Alliance Defending Freedom and the American Center for Law & Justice. Proving to be astute observers of those who came before them, the introduction of CCLOs was soon followed by a much larger, long-term investment in the fight to control politics and law – the founding of Christian conservative law schools and training programs.
Regent University, Liberty University, and Ave Maria Schools of Law, as well as Alliance Defending Freedom’s Blackstone Legal Fellowship, are all institutions established to serve as classic support structures for the conservative Christian legal movement. In the words used by the Blackstone Legal Fellowship, their “goal is to train law students who will rise to positions of influence and leadership as legal scholars, litigators, policy makers and judges. Ideas may have consequences, but people change cultures.” While these institutions could once be dismissed as marginal, the Trump administration’s assent to power, and the president’s recognition that the white Evangelicals who comprise the Christian Right are his strongest and most loyal supporters, political conditions are perfect for this movement to thrive.

As law schools and a training program, though, they are also standalone institutions that have their own interests and wider academic and professional contexts within which they must operate. Given that, while they have been created to serve a specific end, their abilities to realize these ends are not as direct as their founders may have hoped. The needs to secure American Bar Association accreditation, weathering the downturn in the legal market, competing for limited pools of qualified student and faculty, and the need to be accepted by the legal mainstream while preserving their distance from it are some of the challenges these new support structures face in successfully serving their movement. Faced with these challenges and a sudden abundance of political opportunities, our article goes on to detail how each of these institutions seeks to realize its radical mission of challenging secular legalism and their potential to control the law.

Popular posts from this blog

On writing

By Susan Sterett
Law & Society Review Co-Editor

One thing I know for sure after having co-edited Law and Society Review for almost three years is that just about every college and university would like more publications from faculty members. Many colleges and universities around the world want people to write for peer-reviewed journals, so like other journals, Law and Society Review has been getting an increasing number of submissions. Some journals have big backlogs. Some journals have stopped accepting submissions. Everyone is overwhelmed with content. How can you prepare your paper for LSR? This post will point to a few resources that could help, based in my experience from editing, conversations with other editors, and my conversations at the wonderful 2017 sociolegal studies early career workshop at the University of Cape Town. All have made me rethink how I submit to journals.

A few thoughts, most of which are readily found on the internet. Even so, many people may no…

Law & Society Review is pleased to announce two opportunities for scholars who are from or who write about the Global South. Both opportunities have early January deadlines.

The first opportunity is the Sociolegal Studies Early Career Writing Workshop, March 21-23, 2019, at the University of Cape Town. This intensive workshop, co-sponsored by Law & Society Review, is for a small group of early career scholars from any university in Africa to receive feedback on papers in progress and mentoring on writing/publishing processes. The goal is to help one another toward writing goals and publication. The Workshop will cover travel expenses and accommodation. Applications (including draft paper and letter of reference) are due January 14, 2019. For details, please visit the Early Career Workshop website here. For additional questions, contact

Another opportunity is the Law and Society in Africa conference, April 1-3, 2019, organized by American University Cairo's Law & Society Research Unit. The first Law and Society in Africa Conference, held in South Africa in 2016, was a great success, with more than 100 attendees…

How do text messages complicate contemporary sexual assault adjudication?

By Heather Hlavka and Sameena Mulla 
Department of Social and Cultural Sciences, Marquette University

“There’s no video, no injury. It’s purely one hundred percent ‘he said, she said.’ They had a terrible relationship. They were nasty to each other and they don’t get along well, probably never will. But there is no evidence to support the state’s case, other than their words.” Our article, “’That’s How She Talks’: Animating Text Message Evidence in the Sexual Assault Trial,” begins with these familiar words offered by a defense attorney during a sexual assault trial in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The oft-invoked trope of “he said, she said” in cases of sexual violence suggests that without third-party eye witness testimony or material evidence, sexual assault allegations rest on conflicting reports provided by victims, the accused, and other witnesses. But how do trial attorneys reinvent this trope when the words of the witnesses are preserved as text messages?

Text messages are recorded co…